Joe’s New York Pizzeria Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Joe’s New York Pizzeria, a beloved gem located at 200 S Peterboro St in Canastota, NY. This family-owned establishment specializes in delectable pizzas that transport you straight to the heart of New York. With a diverse menu featuring items like the Rustica Pizza and El Diablo, pizza enthusiasts can find a favorite with ease.

Highlights include the Quattro Formaggio and the crowd-pleasing Stuffed Pizza, satisfying even the pickiest of eaters. The pizzeria is not just about pizza; their Stromboli and calzones receive rave reviews for their generous portions and rich flavors.

Customer favorites, along with fast service and a welcoming atmosphere, make each visit memorable. Whether you're stopping for a quick bite or settling in for a family meal, Joe’s promises delightful experiences and consistently delicious food.

Appetizers Specialty Pizza (Prices Vary by Pizza Size, Prices Start as a Small Pizza) Specialty Items (Prices May Vary in Size, Prices Start as a Small) Dinners Cold Subs Hot Subs Desserts Wings (Prices Vary by Order of Wings, Increments by 10)

Appetizers

Small Garlic Bread
US$1.55

Large Garlic Bread
US$3.05

Small Garlic Bread w/ Cheese
US$2.05

Large Garlic Bread w/ Cheese
US$3.55

Mozzarella Sticks
US$7.00

Onion Rings
US$6.45

Jalapeno Poppers

6 Poppers per order
US$6.95

Chicken Fingers

4 Chicken Tenders per order
US$7.45

French Fries
US$3.95

Combo Platter

Mixed fried foods
US$10.00

Fried Ravioli

6 Raviolis per order
US$7.45

Garlic Knots

6 Knots per order
US$3.75

Small Tossed Salad
US$6.50

Large Tossed Salad
US$7.50

Small Antipasto Salad
US$8.00

Large Antipasto Salad
US$10.00

Small Tuna Salad
US$8.00

Large Tuna Salad
US$10.00

Small Crispy Chicken Salad
US$9.00

Large Crispy Chicken Salad
US$11.00

Vegetable Delight
US$22.15

Broccoli & Three Cheese
US$19.70

Popeye
US$18.70

Chicken Wing
US$20.15

White Broccoli Pizza
US$19.70

Chicken Bacon Ranch
US$19.70

The Dickie Diveronica
US$21.15

Garlic Pizza
US$15.70

Supreme
US$22.15

The Carmen Basilio
US$20.15

Bacon Lettuce and Tomato
US$19.70

Hawaiian Pizza
US$18.70

The Billy Backus
US$25.15

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
US$21.15

El Diablo
US$19.15

Sienna
US$20.15

Quattro Formaggio
US$20.15

Bianca Pizza
US$20.15

Mama D's Delight
US$22.15

Rustica Pizza
US$20.15

Tomato Bacon Ranch
US$20.20

Upside Down
US$15.70

Specialty Pizza (Prices Vary by Pizza Size, Prices Start as a Small Pizza)

Specialty Items (Prices May Vary in Size, Prices Start as a Small)

Stromboli Roll
US$21.45

Stuffed Pizza
US$21.45

Personal Calzone
US$11.00

Square Sicilian Pizza
US$19.25

Gluten Free Pizza
US$14.70

Manicotti
US$12.50

Ravioli
US$12.50

Stuffed Shells
US$12.50

Spaghetti
US$12.50

Baked Ziti
US$12.50

Homemade Lasagna
US$12.50

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
US$12.50

Eggplant Parmigiana
US$12.50

Side of Spaghetti
US$2.25

Side of Meatball or Sausage
US$2.25

Dinners

Cold Subs

Small Turkey Sub
US$8.50

Large Turkey Sub
US$9.50

Small Ham Sub
US$8.50

Large Ham Sub
US$9.50

Small Salami Sub
US$8.50

Large Salami Sub
US$9.50

Small Italian Hero
US$8.50

Large Italian Hero
US$9.50

Small Pepperoni Sub
US$8.50

Large Pepperoni Sub
US$9.50

Small Tuna Sub
US$8.50

Large Tuna Sub
US$9.50

Small Meatball Tunnel
US$8.50

Large Meatball Tunnel
US$9.50

Small Sausage Tunnel
US$8.50

Large Sausage Tunnel
US$9.50

Small Steak Sub
US$8.50

Large Steak Sub
US$9.50

Small Chicken Parmigiana
US$8.50

Large Chicken Parmigiana
US$9.50

Small Eggplant Parmigiana
US$8.50

Large Eggplant Parmigiana
US$9.50

Small Chicken Deluxe
US$8.50

Large Chicken Deluxe
US$9.50

Hot Subs

Desserts

(1) Cannoli
US$2.50

(6) Cannoli
US$12.00

10 Wings
US$14.30

10 Boneless Wings
US$9.40

Wings (Prices Vary by Order of Wings, Increments by 10)