Welcome to Joe’s New York Pizzeria
Joe’s New York Pizzeria, located in Canastota, NY, serves up a slice of authentic New York flavor with a welcoming, family-oriented atmosphere. Renowned for its fresh, delicious pizza and hearty Italian staples like homemade lasagna and baked ziti, this local gem has won the hearts of many. Customers rave about the speedy service and the quality of dishes, including their praised cannoli and oversized strombolis. As a family-owned establishment, Joe’s creates a community vibe where every visit feels special. Whether stopping for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, diners consistently leave satisfied and eager to return.
-
200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY 13032, United States200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY 13032, United States Hotline: +1 315-697-3993
When it comes to indulging in authentic culinary experiences, Joe’s New York Pizzeria stands out as a must-visit destination. Located at 200 S Peterboro St, Canastota, NY, this local gem is not just a pizzeria; it's a celebration of New York-style pizza crafted with love and incredible flavors. With a welcoming atmosphere and the quick service praised by many guests, including Heather Phillips who described her experience as “unbelievable,” it’s easy to see why Joe's is beloved by locals and visitors alike.
What makes Joe’s truly special? It's the variety and quality of their offerings. Their specialty pizzas, starting from a modest US$19.15, feature a range of unique options that cater to every palate. Highlights include the Bianca Pizza and the El Diablo, both of which offer exciting flavor profiles that leave diners eager for more. Regular customers like Natasha Zmitrowitz-Ballan laud their consistency, making Joe's a reliable choice for pizza lovers year after year.
Beyond pizza, Joe's menu showcases hearty Italian classics such as Baked Ziti and Manicotti, all priced around US$12.50. The sheer portion sizes, as noted by Edith Young who praised their massive and flavorful Stromboli, ensure that every dish is a filling experience. For those with a sweet tooth, their Cannoli at just US$2.50 provides a delightful end to a satisfying meal.
Customers like SharkMan appreciate Joe's commitment to local business and community, highlighting the friendly staff that makes each visit feel personal. Whether you're stopping for a slice to go or enjoying a sit-down meal, Joe’s New York Pizzeria fosters a family-like atmosphere that invites you to return time and again.
In a world where pizza parlors come and go, Joe’s New York Pizzeria remains a beacon of consistency, flavor, and community spirit. With glowing reviews and a diverse menu, it’s clear that Joe's isn’t just about feeding the hungry; it’s about creating memorable dining experiences. As Mark perfectly put it, “this place has awesome food,” making it a delightful choice for anyone craving genuine New York-style pizza in a warm, welcoming setting.
The slices were fantastic. We stopped in for a quick bite before traveling out of town. The speed of service was unbelievable. Thenslices were fresh and very good! First time stopping, but it will nor be our last.
Best pizza around this area, consistent through the many years we’ve ordered!
After researching top rated eateries, I decided to get my coworkers who live in the area gift certificates to New York Pizzeria. It is a local family owned shop, and I felt it important to support local business. I drove from Syracuse to Canastota to get these gifts. The employees were friendly and it was very difficult not to indulge in the delicious looking slices they had (see pictures!) I will definitely return with my family to eat here.
Hands down ..one of the best Stromboli's I've ever had. My friend and I are traveling to Maine, so we stopped in on the way there. So glad we did. That thing was so huge and full of goodies/flavor. We enjoyed the family like atmosphere. Hope to come back in the future. Edith and Carrie gives you a 10/10
Put it to you this way. My wife is very picky and she said Mark. What a great choice. This place has awesome food. I said I concur honey sure does and the people that run the place are nice too
In from Flordia for a couples days and was referred to New York Pizzeria by a family member and needles to say I was a bit skeptical as I usually head straight to Slice in Utica to tackle my pizza fix. NY Pizzeria knocked it out of the park with their slices. Amazing flavor profile with just the right amount of crunch. Will definitely be back in the future. Keep up the good work.
Delicious pizza very cheesy... subs were good and so were the fried ravioli
Amazing owners and staff, great pizza, good prices! We use New York pizzeria as our go to for family pizza night and events! They always deliver yummy food!